Request for Transparency from BMA

Background

There are credible allegations of multiple cases of abuse at the Light of Hope Orphanage. These allegations include:

These kinds of issues point to significant organizational failures. Some of these persisted for an extended amount of time and were not addressed adequately. Because of this, children and caregivers were left unprotected and without the necessary support.

It is also alleged that the leadership within the orphanage and BMA has attempted to cover up what has happened:

Communication about the situation has been tightly managed. Multiple people have requested an independent investigation. We are inviting others to also join this request.

A trustworthy, experienced organization is needed for the investigation. Based on discussions with legal counsel who have experience in similar situations, Guidepost Solutions is a recommended option. They are respected and have extensive experience with these kinds of situations. We are not proposing GRACE because of concerns some BMA leaders have expressed based on past experience.

There are donors who have offered to contribute significantly to the cost if finances are a barrier to the investigation.

- Josh Nisly, NY

Request

We request an independent third-party investigation into the response to allegations of abuse at the Light of Hope Orphanage. We believe that this is necessary to determine the truth in conflicting accounts, provide accountability, and give recommendations to prevent a similar situation in the future. Our desire is for redemption and for a future that is safer for children and adults in our churches and our ministries. Questions about finances are a secondary issue and are not included in this request.

In the absence of a full investigation, we request BMA leadership to allow a professional independent assessment of the internal investigation that has been done.

Recent Signatures (197 total)

Oct 27, 4:53pm Ruby Doutrich
Oct 19, 11:41am Sheldon Yoder
Oct 18, 6:47pm Caleb Otto
Oct 14, 9:58pm Brendon Doutrich
Oct 10, 1:21am Alaina Gingerich
Oct 9, 9:59pm Lizzi
Oct 1, 9:17pm Julie Hertzler
Oct 1, 8:56pm Russell Hertzler
Oct 1, 8:30pm Katelynn Oberholtzer
Oct 1, 3:17pm Anonymous

See all public signers